Jehovah’s Witness teen in court: Blood transfusion fight fails

0 177

A PREGNANT teenager who rejected potential lifesaving assist for her child on non secular grounds instructed medical doctors: “If the newborn has to die, she has to die.”

The 17-year-old from Victoria, who can’t be named, is 39 weeks pregnant with a child lady. She had been refusing to co-operate with medical doctors at Victoria’s Mercy Hospital who required her permission for a blood transfusion within the occasion she suffers a post-partum haemorrhage throughout labour.

The teenager, who weighed 44kg at 12 weeks pregnant, is taken into account by medical doctors to be at an elevated threat of haemorrhaging as a result of she is of “small stature” and the newborn is giant.

Nevertheless, she mentioned she couldn’t obtain a blood transfusion as a result of it will go in opposition to her non secular beliefs as a Jehovah’s Witness.

Dr Jacqueline van Dam gave proof to the Victorian Supreme Courtroom final month that the teenager is “very quiet and well mannered and seems to depend on her mom to reply questions”.

Dr van Dam mentioned she knowledgeable the teenager of the dangers of blood loss throughout labour. The teenager responded: “I are not looking for blood.”

She mentioned the teenager “appears to be of common mind however is immature” and “believes naively that every one can be properly and that if something occurs she can be protected by her religion”.

Affiliate Professor Campbell Paul, who’s a toddler psychiatrist at The Royal Youngsters’s Hospital in Melbourne, instructed the courtroom he mentioned the issues with the teenager at size.

She instructed him: “The Bible says it’s unsuitable to eat or drink blood in the event you lose blood and need to let it go and pour it out on the ground.”

Later, she additionally instructed him: “If the newborn has to die, she has to die.”

However Justice Cameron Macaulay dominated in opposition to the teenager.

Based on a abstract of the judgment, seen by, Justice Macaulay mentioned the teenager’s stage of maturity and understanding had been contributing components in his choice.

“I ought to take into account whether or not she has ample understanding and intelligence to allow her to grasp totally what’s proposed and the implications of her choice,” he mentioned.

“I ought to kind a view in regards to the extent to which her alternative is a real reflection of who she actually is, and what her beliefs actually are, versus the product of different forces.

“I’m not satisfied that overriding her expressed alternative would so rob her of her important self as to outweigh the loss she would endure by dropping her life or sustaining a catastrophic harm.

“In abstract, I don’t take into account that permitting her, in impact, to decide on to die or solely survive with severe harm is in her greatest pursuits taking into consideration a holistic view of her welfare (bodily, non secular and in any other case).”

Justice Macaulay dominated that the hospital was authorised to manage blood or blood merchandise “as thought-about fairly needed by two registered medical practitioners to avoid wasting her life or to stop severe harm in the course of the course of induction of labour, labour, caesarean part and associated procedures and the post-natal interval in regard to her present being pregnant”.

The hospital was pressured to vow medical doctors would first use methods aside from the transfusion of blood to avert the teenager’s loss of life or severe harm.

The lady’s mom, who moved to Australia together with her household as a refugee in 2009, instructed the courtroom that receiving a blood transfusion would have a major influence on her daughter’s wellbeing.

“Being pressured to have that finished in opposition to her will can be one thing like having violence finished to her or being raped,” she mentioned in a press release learn to the courtroom.

“She desires to do the fitting factor by Jehovah, by God.”

What do you suppose? Proceed the dialog on Twitter with @ro_smith or on e mail:

Supply hyperlink – pregnant/pregnant-jehovahs-witness-loses-fight-to-reject-lifesaving-help-for-her-baby/news-story/e8e01129928ccc63a0de9cec27f454fc

You might also like

Leave A Reply

Your email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.