Donald Trump’s Puerto Rico death toll conspiracy theory

0 162

AS HURRICANE Florence slammed into the coast of the US in current days, Donald Trump was obsessing over the loss of life toll of one other storm, Maria, which devastated the American territory Puerto Rico final yr and left most of its residents with out energy.

A painstaking evaluation carried out by George Washington College and commissioned by the Puerto Rican authorities has concluded 2,975 folks died in Hurricane Maria’s wake, a toll rivalling that of the September 11 terrorist assaults in 2001.

Mr Trump believes that determine has been inflated by his political opponents to make him look unhealthy.

“Three thousand folks didn’t die within the two hurricanes that hit Puerto Rico. After I left the island, AFTER the storm had hit, they’d anyplace from six to 18 deaths. As time glided by it didn’t go up by a lot,” Mr Trump tweeted yesterday.

“Then, a very long time later, they began to report actually massive numbers, like 3000. This was performed by the Democrats in an effort to make me look as unhealthy as attainable after I was efficiently elevating billions of dollars to assist rebuild Puerto Rico.

“If an individual died for any cause, like previous age, simply add them onto the listing. Dangerous politics. I really like Puerto Rico!”

So, does the president’s moderately gorgeous conspiracy principle have any advantage? Let’s take a better take a look at the research.


Maria struck Puerto Rico on September 20, 2017 and reduce energy to 80 per cent of the island.

Hundreds of sick and aged folks have been left with out water, electrical energy or drugs for months, with America’s emergency division FEMA stretched woefully skinny.

Within the fortnight after the storm, as Mr Trump made a fast, four-hour go to to the island, the official loss of life toll did certainly stand at 16, as he has claimed. However in accordance with consultants on the bottom, that toll was woefully inaccurate.

Competing estimates began to look within the ensuing months, a few of which put the true toll at over 1,000.

So, how did George Washington College calculate its determine of two,975?

It examined the variety of “extra deaths” within the six months after Maria hit. Emphasis on the phrase extra.

“Our extra mortality research analysed previous mortality patterns (mortality registration and inhabitants census information from 2010 to 2017) in an effort to predict the anticipated mortality if Hurricane Maria had not occurred (predicted mortality) and examine this determine to the precise deaths that occurred (noticed mortality),” the research says.

It discovered there have been 3000 extra deaths than would often be anticipated throughout these six months.

These deaths may be attributed to the consequences of the hurricane, notably the dearth of entry to well being care amongst Puerto Rico’s poorer residents.

In response to Mr Trump, the research’s authors have known as it “probably the most correct and unbiased estimate of extra mortality to this point”.


Why is Mr Trump so delicate in regards to the reported loss of life toll? It is perhaps as a result of he was accused of offering inadequate help to Puerto Rico in Maria’s aftermath.

He got here below fireplace for jetting off on a golf journey whereas the mayor of the island’s greatest metropolis, San Juan, pleaded for extra assist.

“I’ll do what I by no means thought I used to be going to do — begging. Begging anybody that may hear us to save lots of us from dying. If anyone out there may be listening to us, we’re dying, and you might be killing us with the inefficiency and the forms,” Mayor Carmen Cruz stated.

As a substitute of asking whether or not he actually might do extra, Mr Trump took it as a private assault on him and lashed out at Ms Cruz, who on the time was sleeping in a shelter as a result of her home had been wrecked and was spending her days wading by means of floodwaters making an attempt to assist survivors.

Once more, Mr Trump framed it as an try by his political opponents to disgrace him.

“The mayor of San Juan, who was very complimentary just a few days in the past, has now been advised by Democrats that you simply should be nasty to Trump,” the president stated.

“Such poor management by the mayor of San Juan, and others in Puerto Rico, who are usually not capable of get their employees to assist. They need all the things to be performed for them when it must be a group effort.”

Puerto Rico is a US territory. So simply to be clear, that was the president of the US attacking American catastrophe victims for wanting an excessive amount of of his assist. He felt he was the true sufferer.

Talking to reporters this week, he was filled with reward for his administration’s response to the catastrophe.

“I feel Puerto Rico was extremely profitable,” Mr Trump stated. “I truly assume it was top-of-the-line jobs that’s ever been performed with respect to what that is all about.”


A handful of Mr Trump’s supporters within the media have backed up his gorgeous conspiracy principle in current days.

“The Hurricane Maria loss of life tolls have been inflated and President Donald Trump was proper to name out organisations who threw out science and statistics to attempt to discredit his administration,” stated Fox Enterprise host Lou Dobbs.

“They are saying all these folks died within the storm in Puerto Rico, but 70 per cent of the ability was out earlier than the storm. So when did folks begin dying? At what level do you recognise that what they’re doing is a political agenda couched within the good language of journalism?” stated one other Fox star, Geraldo Rivera.

“The story of Puerto Rico is the rebuilding that has occurred. The president has performed a unprecedented job of clean-up, rebuilding electrical stuff and all the things else.”

Others have slammed Mr Trump for prioritising his personal political standing over the victims of the pure catastrophe.

“We have to cope with the info, which is these 2,975 folks didn’t die of previous age. That’s not true. They didn’t die of previous age, they died of neglect. They’d be alive right now if they’d had electrical energy, if they’d been capable of get drugs, if they’d been capable of get water. These are the folks which are counted,” stated CNN host Alisyn Camerota.

However we are going to give the ultimate phrase to Ms Cruz, the San Juan mayor who as soon as begged for Mr Trump’s assist.

“That is what denial following neglect appears to be like like,” stated Ms Cruz.

“Mr President in the true world folks died in your watch. Your lack of respect is appalling.

“Disgrace on you.”

Supply hyperlink –

You might also like